We are Sarwa

A one-stop shop for self-directed trading and auto-investing. We're making powerful money management tools available for all.
Learn more.

The reality is the market always moves in cycles. It is its nature. Data shows that being out of the market in times of uncertainty has been quite costly for investors. 

We wanted to share with you the facts and numbers.

According to studies, a lump sum invested in October of 1929 ( the worst possible period of the Great Crash) in a balanced portfolio with no other money added would have returned a compounded average of 8.02% per year. Yet Very few investors end up earning that return. The reason behind this underperformance is that we let our emotions get the best of us: we panic-sell or we think we can time the market properly. 

To be a good investor you should have no attachment to any short term movement of the markets at all. What you do not want to do is to pull out and sell on the low. You also don’t want to try to time when to move in and out. 
Andrew Hallam studied the top Tactical Asset Allocation funds trained analysts, whose job is to move buy/sell constantly to provide their funds with a sharp profit edge. These ‘experts’ keep their eyes on global interest rates, tax cuts, corporate earnings projections and market valuations…

  • During the 5-year period ending June 13, 2018, the best ones averaged a compound annual return of  6.11% per year. 
  • A more diversified portfolio of indexes (40% U.S. bonds, 40% U.S. stocks, 20% international stocks) would have averaged a return of 7.75 %.

The result?  A diversified portfolio of low-cost index funds beats the top experts who tried to timed the market.

When you move your money, you try to do what these tactical professional investors do. No-one can properly time the market. By attempting to do so, you can easily miss out on the best performing days. Let’s look into a recent example: Between March 23 and 26, the market returned an average of 19%. If you were out of the market for these 3 days, you would have missed out on the rebound! Research shows that staying fully invested through the bear markets would lead to greater returns than moving investments into cash.

When we keep listening to the different financial news when volatility hits, we are tempted to mess with your sound investment strategy. 

Claims of successful market timing are mainly a result of a mix of luck and data snooping

Sarwa analyzed the different periods over the last 30 years based on different actions scenarios to better understand the impact of trying to move in and out of the market. Dr. Jiro Kondo, our Head of Portfolio Construction and MIT phd in Financial Economy,  looked into the impact of pulling out of the market and sitting in cash, even for days. In this analysis, a dollar invested in 1990/01/01 would be worth 6.803 dollars today. 

Hypothetical portfolio of investments in the S&P 500. Past performance is no guarantee of future results. The examples are provided for illustrative purposes only. Investors may not achieve similar results. The example does not reflect the effects of fees and potential costs. 

What this tells us is that the simple strategy of just staying invested throughout (Scenario 1) beats the ‘timing the market’ strategies explored. In some cases, the difference in performance is substantial. For instance, with Scenario 3, the market timing strategy that exits when the market drops by 30% and re-enters following a run-up of 10%, you would earn 21.5% less. This major shortfall occurs despite only being out of the market for 33 days –  highlighting how exiting the market for even a short period of time can greatly harm investment performance.

We’ve looked at several other investment periods as well (e.g., post-1970, post-World War II, post-2000) and similar results arise. Our conclusion: at best, market timing does not work and is based on speculation and luck. 

If you sell during a downturn, you actually realize your losses. More generally, history suggests that being out of the market in times of high uncertainty, which follows market downturns, has been quite costly because it reduces an investor’s ability to benefit from market recoveries. These recoveries usually occur in quick bursts that are unpredictable and almost impossible to time.

Abandoning course can be costly. Keep calm and keep invested. You don’t want to miss out on recovery.

Ready to invest in your future? Talk to our advisory team, we will be happy to help.
Important Disclosure:

The information provided in this blog is for general informational purposes only. It should not be considered as personalised investment advice. Each investor should do their due diligence before making any decision that may impact their financial situation and should have an investment strategy that reflects their risk profile and goals. The examples provided are for illustrative purposes. Past performance does not guarantee future results. Data shared from third parties is obtained from what are considered reliable sources; however, it cannot be guaranteed. Any articles, daily news, analysis, and/or other information contained in the blog should not be relied upon for investment purposes. The content provided is neither an offer to sell nor purchase any security. Opinions, news, research, analysis, prices, or other information contained on our Blog Services, or emailed to you, are provided as general market commentary. Sarwa does not warrant that the information is accurate, reliable or complete. Any third-party information provided does not reflect the views of Sarwa. Sarwa shall not be liable for any losses arising directly or indirectly from misuse of information. Each decision as to whether a self-directed investment is appropriate or proper is an independent decision by the reader. All investing is subject to risk, including the possible loss of the money invested.

-->